Playpen

Welcome to the Playpen, our space for ferrety banter and whimsical snippets of things that aren't quite long enough for articles (although they might be) but that caught your eye anyway.

at 21:32 on 03-11-2010, Arthur B
I would definitely hope that wanking and volunteering at a soup kitchen are mutually exclusive activities.
permalink
at 19:47 on 03-11-2010, Alasdair Czyrnyj
I just finished reading it, and it's not wanky at all. In fact, it's anti-wank, which I think would logically be...volunteering at a soup kitchen? I have no idea how to complete that analogy. Maybe someone could help me.

Ahem.

Anyway, it was a very helpful post that actually helped crystallize some of my longstanding misgivings about steampunk as a mode of fantastic literature (or whatever). It certainly explained why it seems to be so damned uninterested in doing anything involving actual history or proto-scifi (which was where most of its tropes came from). It also explains my problem with it little sister sub-sub-thingy "dieselpunk"; everyone is content to putter around in noir America and in pulp magazines while I want to probe the social dynamics of fascist states.
permalink
at 18:59 on 03-11-2010, Wardog
Oh noes - I like her a lot and now I'm scared to read in case she's wanky.

Also I'd just like to say: WE HATED STEAMPUNK HERE FIRST ;)

(except Alasdair)
permalink
at 18:12 on 03-11-2010, Niall
Catherynne Valente weighs in on steampunk.
permalink
at 21:45 on 01-11-2010, Niall
This is another one of those "get off my side" things isn't it.


I feel that way about a lot of what Stross writes, yeah.

The goths-discover-brown thing is not original to him, either.
permalink
at 21:33 on 01-11-2010, Alasdair Czyrnyj
In happier news, I think that piece has inspired my next two articles for FerretBrain.
permalink
at 21:32 on 01-11-2010, Alasdair Czyrnyj
Okay, this bit pisses me right the fuck off.

The romanticization of totalitarianism is nothing new (and if you don't recognize the totalitarian urge embedded in the steampunk nostalgia trip, I should like to remind you that "king" is a synonym for "hereditary dictator" and direct you to the merciless skewing Michael Moorcock delivered to imperial hagiography in his Oswald Bastable books).

Let me explain something here. "Totalitarian" is a very particular word that describes a very specific type of social system. Say whatever you want about the ancien régime, but it was not a totalitarian enterprise. It was based on long-standing traditions of feudalism, filial piety, and religion, which it was the duty of the ruling class to maintain. In a totalitarian society, all of those are abandoned because they are no longer seem as being able to provide any sort of adequate guide to human behavior, leaving it the job of the ruling class to reconstruct every aspect of civilization into a new holistic entity capable of resolving the contradictions of the modern world and ushering in a joyous new society in which there are no complaints. The two are literally worlds apart, and to suggest otherwise is deeply disingenuous.

God, this type of sloppy thinking makes me so fucking angry...

Incidentally, that book Stross is looking for has already been written, after a fashion.
permalink
at 19:14 on 01-11-2010, Arthur B
Also, actual Victorians wrote books criticising the social order of their time. (To pull a line directly from Stross's post, that's where "Dickensian" comes from.) What's stopping steampunk authors doing the same, aside from the impossibility of doing any first-hand resea- oh wait actually that does kind of put a cramp on things. But they can criticise our society whilst pretending to criticise the Victorians with as much authority, and we can recognise things that were fucked up about the 19th Century today which even commentators at the time wouldn't have picked up on.
permalink
at 18:35 on 01-11-2010, Dan H
This is another one of those "get off my side" things isn't it.

What really annoys me about the "but those bits of history were really bad" criticisms is that they're blatantly written by people who have never read any of the source material. One of the many, many wanky tropes of Steampunk is *exactly* the kind of excessive grittiness that Stross insists people would never ever write about.

As a criticism of a subgenre, it's about as sophisticated as - no check that, *entirely identical to* - arguing that Fantasy sucks because real medieval Europe was nasty. It's like complaining about /The Princess Bride/ on the basis that real pirates were horrible.

I also really don't understand the bit where he says: "Maybe it's on its way to becoming a new sub-genre, or even a new shelf category in the bookstores. But in the meantime, it's over-blown."

So ... currently Steampunk novels are all trashy and derivative, but somehow if we put them on a shelf on their own, they'd magically become legitimate texts again?

That said, I did snicker at "steampunk is what happens when goths discover brown".
permalink
at 16:59 on 01-11-2010, Arthur B
Seems a pretty hit and miss argument to me. I completely agree with the second artist effect. I can sort of see his point about the politics, but then again if the point of steampunk is to write about a counterfactual Victorian-ish era surely the facts of politics in the setting can be counterfactual in turn, in just the same way you can choose to have a constitutional monarchy with something resembling democratic accountability in a high fantasy story if you don't want to deal with the icky absolutist side of kingship.

But complaining about the technology is just daft. Steampunk's an aesthetic, not an alternative form of hard SF, and citing Tim "Stilt Magic" Powers as an exemplar of good steampunk and then saying that the science isn't up to scratch is just silly.
permalink
at 00:16 on 30-10-2010, Jamie Johnston
A rather delightful short Sherlock fic for fans of the antidote to panel games. (via.)
permalink
at 23:46 on 29-10-2010, Alasdair Czyrnyj
Okay, this is most disturbing thing I've seen all month. At least it's actually being played as disturbing, unlike in certain films (coughWatchmencoughKickAsscough).
permalink
at 17:27 on 29-10-2010, Arthur B
Dear misogygeeks: if you can't say something genuinely nice to Kate Beaton, please don't say it at all.
permalink
at 15:23 on 29-10-2010, Andy G
More alternative gears here.
permalink
at 08:58 on 29-10-2010, Shimmin
This is unreasonably cool: alternative gears (you don't need to speak German for this, despite the link)
permalink
at 11:03 on 27-10-2010, Wardog
There were vests in The L Word too, but they were not universal. Maybe there are no bras in Glasgow...

It's not an outright rip - it's about the interwined lives of three women and their friends, and one of them has a deep dark mystery of mysterious darkness going on. Actually it's quite watchable and on Iplayer for anybody in England who fancies it.

I can't tell whether to sexscenes are a step up a sidegrade though. They don't have telepathetic lesbian orgasms, since there is always definitely a hand in the correct location to inspire orgasm ... but the recommended methodology for making a woman come, if you are a woman, seems to be what's best described as a vertical jackhammer motion down the front of her pants.

:/

permalink
at 10:43 on 27-10-2010, Arthur B
So, are they trying to do an outright rip-off of the L-Word (plus vests), or do they go out of their way to make it all gritty and Scottish (and vesty)?
permalink
at 10:24 on 27-10-2010, Wardog
Everything I learned about being gay from Lipservice: all proper lesbians wear vests.

:(
permalink
at 01:31 on 27-10-2010, Alasdair Czyrnyj
Good news, everyone! I have finally joined the rest of Western civilization and started playing Team Fortress 2. My, what a delightful game. Just running around and
shooting/exploding/stabbing/incinerating people 24/7.

I am starting to wonder how long I'll have to wait to get a fireman hat for my Pyro, though.
permalink
at 23:18 on 21-10-2010, Arthur B
Done. Kind of.
permalink
at 22:33 on 20-10-2010, Shimmin
Me like. Someone should write their next article with a compatible title.
permalink
at 21:38 on 20-10-2010, Arthur B
I just want to point out that if you put together the titles of the top three articles on the front page you get "Smothered At Birth And Blaming It On You Friggin' Nerds".
permalink
at 21:43 on 19-10-2010, Wardog
Omg, look at that! Somebody did :D
permalink