Welcome to the Playpen, our space for ferrety banter and whimsical snippets of things that aren't quite long enough for articles (although they might be) but that caught your eye anyway.
What with all the rape and the "A noun proposition noun" title I was sure you guys were discussing a recently-unearthed George R R Martin text.
A Song of Ice & Fire, Book 9:
A Rape of Everybody
I guess rape is, to me, an absolute nadir of horrible that I can't think of a rapist character as remotely appealing or sympathetic in any way. It's like the eunuch in Cindy Pon's novels; he tries his damnedest to rape the heroine, and what does he get? Fandom (such as there is) adoration, complete with a second book that focuses entirely on him and basically absolves him with "he's only misunderstood! He only tried to rape her because he's IN LOVE with her!" It stinks so much of rape culture; the Vico thing is very similar, but more so.
Incidentally, in ADwR you can (grossness warning)
TRIGGER WARNINGS. TALKING ABOUT NASTY STUFF.
I don't know how to express this without sounding INSANE but I'm not objectively bothered by the notion that a rapist could also be a romantic lead (I read romance, after all, and although it's a horrible idea in real terms, romance is romance is romance). And the characters in ADwR are generally written successfully enough that I find them reasonably interesting and psychologically complex.
But what really really freaks me out is not the rape fantasy stuff - I mean whatever floats your boat, right? - it's the way rape is consistently presented as being based in desire. I'm sorry but people don't rape people because they *fancy* them. That's like saying you beat people up because you admire their strength. And I know it's a common romance/erotica trope but for some reason there's just something about the way it's presented in ADwR that freaks me the fuck out.
I think the Twilight analogy is an apt one actually - fantasy is fine, but fantasy *without awareness* is bloody dangerous.
The other thing that really bothered me about ADwR is there's so much sex and rape that it ends up *normalising* rape. There's even a hilarious line near the beginning where they're talking about the invasion of the castle and one dude turns to another dude and is like "this is totes srs business, dude, they're not even stopping to rape the women." (paraphrased)
I don't understand why the ADwR fandom likes Vico so much, and it's evident too that he's Valine's favorite character. :/
I mean it's all just fail fail fail fail. The homophobia and the whole attitude to the text.
*cries in the corner*
Incidentally, the subject came up elsewhere but it got me curious: did anyone ever play the NWN1 mods called "A Dance with Rogues"?
I wonder what the English Dept at BYU thinks of it.
Answer: It would be reeeeeallly homophobic.
Have to thank Aladair for pointing out this site. I am just baffled at the amount of awesome material on John J. Riley's home page, but I also wonder why the website itself is so damn ugly.
Are there any "Your adventure ends here" outcomes?
Yep. On my second playthrough I got sent home unmarried. The finishing screen did drop the hint that
Robinson: [Star Wars prequel fans are] decidedly in minority, but yes, we are out there.
Alasdair: Really? Just out of curiosity, what do you like about them? This isn't the setup for a joke or anything; I'd just like to know.
Sorry it's taken me so long to respond - I was out of town all weekend with no internet access. I just know that after I post this, at least three people are going to jump in and explain why they think the prequels are awful. Which is just fine (I'll probably even agree with some of the points), but these are some of my reasons for liking them. I recognize numerous places where they are flawed, but I love them anyway.
Okay so, my reasons for being a fan include:
The score. John Williams' work on the originals has rightly been praised far and wide, and I believe he did a comparable job on the prequels. "Duel of the Fates" and to a lesser extent "Battle of the Heroes" and the one that plays at the end of Phantom Menace are just spectacular, as far as I'm concerned.
A lot of the dialogue in these movies gets (deservedly) mocked, but there are a number of really good lines, too. Anakin's and Obi-Wan's banter in the first half hour or so of Revenge of the Sith is great, and so is the way they play off each other in Attack of the Clones (even when the other isn't really there).
While we're on the subject, a lot of the relationships between the characters are really good. Anakin and Obi-Wan of course, but also Anakin and Palpatine and a lot of the smaller, background relationships. The "love dialogue" between Anakin and Padme often makes me cringe, as do the parts where Anakin acts like a total idiot, but I find there's more to their romance than just those, and what's left over strikes me as really nice.
And I do like the characters. Anakin gets annoying at times, but I think a lot of the stuff he does is actually pretty cool, like casually hopping out of a speeder to catch the would-be assassin in Clones, or landing General Grevious' flagship in Sith. I like Padme as well, though I feel Lucas ultimately wasted most of her potential as a character. I like Obi-Wan and Qui-Gon and Mace Windu and Count Dooku, and I think Palpatine in the prequels makes for a much more awesome villain than he does in Return of the Jedi, honestly. Honestly, I even like Jar Jar Binks.
I could go on all day, but that's probably more than most people on this site are interested in hearing anyway. Does it answer your question?